Bluebird and Small Cavity Nester Conservation
Sialis - Bluebirds and other small cavity nesters
 
bluebirds

eggsHill Trail - started in 2006

See description of Hill Trail and aerial photo, and photos from 2007 | 2008 log | 2009 log.
Also see other trail logs. This is an experimental trail in a HOSP infested area where I am not trapping.

In September 2006, I set up a experimental two-hole mansion trail with 5 boxes made and donated by Linda Violett of California (see photo, courtesy of Linda Violett). The boxes are hanging from trees on a small town green surrounded by farms and residences. There were 7 existing HOSP-infested, pole-mounted boxes there (see photos) that I stumbled across and obtained permission to manage. Bluebirds have been seen in the area. Note: Two of the boxes went missing - one in 2006, one in 2009 - from climbable trees. I have another two-holed mansion that is pole-mounted on the Chimalis trail. It has not been used yet.

The Experiment: The existing pole mounted boxes (no baffles) were plugged in 2007. In Year 2, someone unplugged the single-holed boxes. No HOSP trapping was conducted, in order to evaluate whether EABLs are able to secure and successfully defend the two-hole mansions despite HOSP competition. I am removing any HOSP nests and eggs on at least a weekly basis.

I'm doing this experiment for two reasons: 1) I believe that about half of serious bluebirders prefer passive alternatives to HOSP control or are unwilling to take any steps to keep HOSp out of boxes, and 2) I want to gather data about two-hole box usage by EABLs. I can't wait to see what happens, although I admit it will be hard to potentially allow some losses to HOSP. I also want to limit the variables so I can assess the two-holers. (I do use ground and inbox traps as needed on my other trails). Squirrels may be an issue with the hanging boxes, as red, grey and flying squirrels are common in this area.

Conclusions SO FAR (as of 03/09):

Here are my opinions, based on two full seasons (2007 and 2008) and one partial season (2008).  However, be aware that I only have four of these hanging two holed boxes. I also have 80+ pole mounted boxes.
 
PROS:
  • Increased species diversity (which is something I WANT).  In 2008, one of the only TUTI nesting was in a two-holed mansions, along with one of only two WBNU nestings (one in a 2 holer, one in a tree-mounted one holer - both were successful.  In 2007, I had only three TUTI's attempts on my trail, of which two were in the hanging boxes (unfortunately both failed due to HOSP and HOWR competition.) The 2008 TUTI attempt in the two-holer failed due to House Wren predation.
  • One EABL pair able to successfully fledge two young in HOSP-infested territory in 2007. (Nest built after trees leafed out.)
  • Safer from predation compared to a tree or telephone-pole mounted box.  The large overhanging roof, hook and deep box probably offer some protection against raccoons and definitely against almost all cats.  (No snakes in my area.) The two-hole mansion is deeper which offers additional protection (although I find users build bigger, higher nests.)
  • Safer from vandalism or stealing, ONLY if camoflaged (if hung high enough in a tree that is not readily climbed.
  • No mice problems.
  • Cheaper system (no pole mountings system or predator guards) - a big advantage for a large trail.
  • Low utilization by Tree Swallows?  (None so far in any hanging boxes or the pole-mounted box in Tree Swallow territory)
  • The two-hole mansion is very roomy inside.
  • The two hole mansion probably enables adults to escape more readily from a HOSP inbox attack.
  • HOSP interest seemed to decline after trees leafed out.

CONS:

  • Harder to monitor than a pole-mounted box, and takes longer (must have lifter or ladder on hand, takes about 2-3 times longer to monitor, tricky to get the technique down, concern about dropping box and disturbing contents and incubating female.) The two-hole mansion per Linda's specs is very heavy.
  • Harder to vandalize (as long as they are hung high enough in a tree that is difficult to climb) BUT the only two boxes ever lost on my trail were these. Both are apparently too close to a posh high school. The first one was too low in a climbable apple tree. The second was in a larger, but climbable tree.
  • Appeal to Flying Squirrels, which may predate nestbox contents. (Personally, I think it is cool to have Flying Squirrels nesting in a box though.)  I have never had Flyers in my pole mounted boxes, but in year one had them in 2 out of 4 hanging boxes (however, Linda's boxes are larger than a typical single-holed box.) I have seen Flying Squirrels using pole-mounted boxes in a nearby unmonitored trail on a golf course, where boxes are at forest edge.
  • Predator problems: Snake access? (no direct experience). Roof rats (not in my area.)  Honeybees? (I have only had bumblebees in mouse nests in pole-mounted boxes.)
  • Low utilization by bluebirds SO FAR.  No bluebird attempt until trees had leafed out and HOSP pressure declined in year 1. No bluebird attempts at all in year 2.
  • Some people don't have good "hanging" trees in suitable habitat.
  • The two-hole mansion has a large interior, and users tend to build larger, bulkier nests which takes more time and energy.
  • Unfortunately these boxes are not HOWR-resistant (no boxes I've used so far are!)
UNANSWERED QUESTIONS:
  • Do bluebirds, HOSP, HOWR or TRES PREFER hanging or pole-mounted boxes if given a choice?  So far it seems like TUTI's prefer the hanging boxes, and possibly nuthatches.
  • Do hanging boxes get fewer paper wasps? (A BIG problem on my trails.)
  • Will I be able to duplicate Linda Violett's success raising bluebirds in HOSP infested areas with few losses?
Linda Violett's Two-Hole Mansion with lifter   Hill Trail Location - via Google Earth
YEAR # boxes EABL TUTI TRES BCCH HOSP Flying Squrrl WBNU HOWR

2006 (before Two-Holed Mansions)

7
0
0
? possibly 1 or 2
0
6 or 7+
0
0
0
2007
4
1 nest - 2 fldged
0 - 2 attmpts Failed
0
0
0 - Failed
2 used
0
0 -Failed
2008
4
0
1 attempt Failed
0
0
0
2 used
1 nest - 8 fldged
0
KEY
BCCH = Black-capped Chickadee
EABL = Eastern Bluebird
HOSP = House Sparrow
NABS = NABs style nestbox
PETE = Peterson style nestbox
PW=paper wasp
SLOT = Slot style entrance on nestbox
TRES = Tree Swallow
WBNU = White-breasted Nuthatch
NOTE: THE 2006 LOG BELOW and drawing SHOW USE OF THE TRAIL BEFORE TWO-HOLE HANGING MANSIONS WERE INSTALLED
ID Type Attempt #, Species & Fate 8/10/06 Roosting
Evidence
1/07/07
1 NABS HOSP - blue feathers None.
2 SLOT HOSP - saw male perching Pine needles - EABL?
3 NABS HOSP Chewed hole. Cracked.
4 NABS HOSP? TRES? grass and lots of white poop - HOSP? Top is split.
5 NABS HOSP Mouse nest? Grass and leaves without cup.
6 NABS HOSP - active, 4 eggs on 8/10 EABL (pine needles, saw them attempting to enter after plugging)
7 NABS HOSP, poss TRES. seed heads. Few pieces of grass
Hill Trail, box layout

8/10/06: cleaned out contents of all boxes. Some split roofs. Looks like boxes had not been emptied in years. See photos. No sign of paper wasps.
9/06: Installed 5 new two-holed mansions in trees. Saw at least one male EABL. See 2007 log of activity.


    Daddy dear, tell me please, is the world really round? Tell me where is the bluebird of happiness found?
    - Little Child (Mon Enfant), Wes Montgomery, Ralph Towner, Spike Jones

HOME | Basics | Resources | House Sparrows | House Wrens | Nest/Egg ID | Site Map and Search | Suet Recipes | Tree Swallows | Contact me Bluebird Conservation

May all your blues be birds!

If you experience problems with the website/find broken links/have suggestions/corrections, please contact me!
The purpose of this site is to share information with anyone interested in bluebird conservation.
Feel free to link to it (preferred as I update content regularly), or use text from it for personal or educational purposes, with a link back to http://www.sialis.org or a citation for the author.
No permission is granted for commercial use.
Appearance of automatically generated Google or other ads on this site does not constitute endorsement of any of those services or products!

Photo in header by Wendell Long.
© Original photographs are copyrighted, and may not be used without the express permission of the photographer. Please honor their copyright protection.
See disclaimer, necessitated by today's sadly litigious world.
Last updated March 24, 2016. Design by Chimalis.

Chimalis